This is how the Atlantic box looked like;
And this is the reissued Nexus box;
As with all ancient Atlantic sets, the box art is a pic of the painted soldiers, with superb painting skills and a very good selection of colours. The Nexus box just reuses the photo, using it horizontally as Italeri and other manufacturers do today.
This is what the figures look like;
(They are tan in Nexus reissue, and there is some other Atlantics set with a sort of tan-orangey colour. Probably there were made in many other colours too)
SCULPTING - 7.8 out of 10
As with other Atlantic ancient sets, the level of sculpting is nice and high. Detail is sharp and they can be nicely painted, but the figures have some not every interesting poses (too many spearmen just carrying the spear without doing anything with it) and I am still trying to make out what the archer is doing holding the bow in that position at the same time as he carries an axe and having no quiver for his arrows. They also seem a bit skinny and tall, maybe they would be skinny in a bad year for crops, but probably not so tall.
All the same, you get a good number of poses, and generally they are anatomically right (at least far more than brands like Strelets, or some Italeri sets with big heads).
HISTORICAL ACCURACY - 8.5 out of 10
They are a sort of mish-mash remix of different eras, but overall they are correct, and as the Egyptian empire spawns for 3 millennia I think you could find a spot where all men fit. In our days we would probably demand 3 sets for correctly covering the subject, but back in the 70s and until very recently, you wanted Egyptians and you didn't care about anything more.
The worst figure arguably is the Pharaoh. At least this is what we deduct, as he carries the crown of the Lower Egypt. But he doesn't have any sort of armour or fancy clothes, he only carries a sort of sceptre (normally the Pharaoh would go to battle in chariot and he would use either a bow, or a more sophisticated type of weapon), and worst of all, a regular shield like the other infantry.
The Pharaoh was quite an important person, and he had commodities such as shield-bearers to protect him, so this leaves this figure as simply a general or somebody of the royal family, who most probably didn't wear the crown (this is furtherly confirmed as Atlantic also made a Pharoah figure ), so you would have to cut his crown to be more historically accurate.
ARMY REPRESENTATION - 2.5
"The army representation score is the potential of the soldiers to be used for other purposes different to the one originally intended"
These figures have Egyptian written on their faces, and they can't be used for anything else really. Some of the figures with a bit of modification could be made into Meroe and Aksum infantry, but not much more.
FUNNESS - 8.0
"I feel that many reviews are oblivious to this point - there are fantastic figures, which you can´t say anything against, but they are just too "correct", maybe too static, and so just boring. So I feel that this is an important consideration on deciding if you buy this set"
They are Egyptians! until the Caesar set, they were the only Egyptians you could buy, and from the late 80s until the Nexus reissue, even these were not available. How has mankind survived the lack of 1/72 during so much time? I wonder. Just for being what they are their level of funness is huge.
WARGAMING VALUE - 8.0
Except the lack of archers (which you can easily solve getting the Atlantic Egyptian Cavalry set)
this is a very good set for wargaming. For other unique characters you have the Atlantic At the Pharaohs Court set.
PRICE-VALUE RATIO - 10.0
"The price value ratio of these soldiers will vary between every shop you go to, and the best I can do is judge by their average price on eBay"
Nexus no longers reissues these figures, but all the same by eBay you easily can find the infantry, either the original or reissue, for a very good price, hence the 10.0 score. I bought mine for 9,99 € I think, which for Nexus reissue, that gives you 62 figures, is a great price. Just be alert, and you'll find a second hand lot for roughly 8 GBP shipped.
PAINTING AND GLUEING - 5.5
Both the Atlantic and Nexus are not very good to paint or to glue,being flexible and slippery. Note that although they never had flash problems in this set, there is a bit of flash present in Nexus sets, so you will have to cut it, and it is not easy as the plastic is very elastic.
OVERALL VALORATION - 8.5
I had lived without any Egyptian miniatures for too long, and these were the answer to my miniature prayings. For me, not having Egyptians was like missing Greeks or Romans, and so I am bit biased in favour of this set, but I think even now, with good Zvezda and Caesar sets, they have a more "Egyptian" flavour in this set than in the others. So even now, I recommend this set over their competitors. Besides this, the other sets depict the later armies of the Egyptians, so for early Egyptians, this is still the one and only set.
"Your figures could appear here if you want! just send me a email with the pictures to firstname.lastname@example.org and I´ll gladly include them"
These figures have been painted by myself.
Thanks to Gabriel from http://1-72degabriel.blogspot.com/2010/02/infanteria-egipcia-2300-1500-ac.html for giving his permissionm to show his greatly painted Egyptians! ;
Thanks for reading, and see you in the next battle!
Post a Comment